What are The Pros and Cons of Building a Barndominium in Idaho

Many homeowners and prospective buyers often wonder if building a barndominium is the right choice for them. Interestingly, recent statistics indicate a surge in barndominium construction, with more people in Idaho turning to this cost-effective and versatile housing option. 

As we move into 2025, the appeal of barndominiums continues to grow, thanks to their affordability, durability, and customizable designs. But is this trend suitable for everyone? This article dives into the pros and cons of barndominiums, exploring why they might (or might not) be the perfect choice for Idaho residents.

The Pros of Building a Barndominium in Idaho

Barndominiums Are Cheaper to Build Than Standard Homes

One of the most appealing aspects of barndominiums in Idaho is their lower construction costs compared to traditional homes. Barndominiums often cost significantly less to build than traditional homes, with savings of up to 50% in some cases. 

For Idaho residents, the affordability is a major draw. Traditional homes in Idaho average $400–$500 per square foot, while barndominiums can cost as little as $200 per square foot. This is primarily due to the simplified construction process and the use of steel as the primary material, which is more affordable and easier to source than wood.

Labor costs are also reduced, as barndominiums typically require fewer specialized contractors. Additionally, the streamlined design reduces waste, further lowering costs. If budget constraints are a priority, this housing option offers immense financial relief.

One of the primary reasons homeowners are drawn to barndominiums is their affordability. Compared to traditional homes, barndominiums can save you a significant amount of money during construction. Here’s a breakdown of average costs to highlight the difference:

Tip: “Consider purchasing materials locally to save on transportation costs and support Idaho-based suppliers.”

Barndominiums Come in an Easy-to-Assemble Kit

The availability of barndominium kits in Idaho simplifies the construction process. These prefabricated kits include all the necessary materials and instructions, making it possible for DIY enthusiasts to tackle construction themselves. Many Idaho builders also specialize in assembling these kits, allowing homeowners to oversee the process while saving on labor costs.

The prefabricated components also mean quicker construction timelines. On average, a barndominium can be built in six months or less, compared to traditional homes, which can take a year or more. This speed is especially advantageous for those eager to settle into their new home quickly.

Note: “Opt for kits that include insulation suited for Idaho’s cold winters to ensure energy efficiency.”

Barndominiums Are Cost-effective Over Conventional Houses

The cost to build a barndominium in Idaho is one of its greatest advantages. While the initial expenses for materials may seem high, the long-term savings in maintenance and energy efficiency make it a cost-effective choice. Steel structures require less maintenance than wood-framed houses, cutting down on repair expenses. Additionally, the energy efficiency of barndominiums can lead to significant savings on utility bills, with energy costs reduced by up to 25% in well-insulated designs.

In Idaho, where utility costs can spike during winter, these savings can make a substantial difference. By combining lower initial construction costs with ongoing savings, barndominiums emerge as a financially savvy housing option.

Tip: “Invest in high-quality insulation and energy-efficient windows to maximize your savings over time.”

Imagination Unleashed in Designing Your Space

One of the most appealing aspects of barndominiums is their design flexibility. From open-concept layouts to rustic finishes, barndominium design ideas cater to a wide range of preferences. Idaho’s rural charm lends itself to creative designs that integrate natural elements like wood beams and large windows to capture scenic views.

The flexibility of barndominium floor plans allows homeowners to create spaces tailored to their lifestyle, whether it’s for family living, hobbies, or a home office. For those with hobbies or businesses requiring extra space, a barndominium can be customized to meet these unique needs.

Note: “Work with an experienced designer to create a floor plan that balances functionality with style.”

You Can Live in Your Barndominium While Finishing the Interior

A practical advantage of barndominiums is the ability to move in before the interior is fully finished. This eliminates the need for temporary housing, reducing overall costs. Many Idaho homeowners take this approach, focusing on completing essential areas like kitchens and bathrooms first while finishing other spaces over time. This phased approach allows homeowners to spread out expenses and make adjustments based on their evolving needs. It’s an excellent solution for those looking to save money without compromising on comfort.

Tip: “Prioritize insulating and sealing the structure before moving in to ensure comfort during Idaho’s colder months.”

Barndominiums Provide a Lot of Extra Space

Barndominiums are renowned for their spacious layouts. The open floor plans provide ample room for combining living areas with workspaces, storage, or recreational zones. In Idaho, where many residents value space for farming equipment, vehicles, or hobbies, this flexibility is particularly advantageous. 

The extra space also makes barndominiums ideal for families, as they can be easily adapted to include additional bedrooms or play areas. Whether you need room for a growing family or a home-based business, a barndominium can accommodate your lifestyle.

Note: “Plan for storage solutions early on to keep your space organized and functional.”

Barndominiums Offer Enhanced Durability Compared to Traditional Homes

Steel structures are more resistant to weather and pests than traditional wood-framed homes. As durable homes in Idaho, barndominiums stand up well to snow, wind, and pests. Steel frames are less likely to warp, rot, or be damaged by termites, ensuring your home stands the test of time. With proper maintenance, a barndominium can last decades longer than a conventional home, making it a sound investment for Idaho residents seeking long-term value.

Tip: “Apply rust-resistant coatings to protect the steel frame from Idaho’s variable climate conditions.”

Barndominiums Degrade More Slowly Than Standard Homes

The longevity of steel structures means fewer repairs and replacements over the years. Unlike wood, steel is not prone to decay, and it retains its structural integrity for decades. This slower degradation process translates to lower maintenance costs and fewer disruptions to your living environment. For Idaho homeowners looking for a low-maintenance housing option, barndominiums offer peace of mind and significant savings on upkeep.

Note: “Regularly inspect your barndominium for signs of wear to catch potential issues early.”

Barndominiums Embody a Greener Housing Alternative

Barndominiums are inherently eco-friendly, thanks to their use of recyclable materials and energy-efficient designs. Steel, the primary material used, is 100% recyclable, reducing the environmental impact of construction. Additionally, many barndominium owners incorporate solar panels and energy-efficient insulation to further minimize their carbon footprint. 

Eco-friendly barndominiums reduce environmental impact by minimizing construction waste and lowering energy consumption. This makes barndominiums an excellent choice for eco-conscious Idaho residents seeking sustainable housing solutions.

Tip: “Look for locally sourced materials to reduce transportation emissions and support Idaho’s economy.”

Barndominiums Are a More Eco-Friendly Housing Option

Beyond construction, barndominiums offer ongoing environmental benefits. Energy-efficient designs help reduce reliance on non-renewable resources, particularly in Idaho’s cold winters and hot summers. By optimizing insulation and ventilation, barndominiums can maintain comfortable temperatures year-round with minimal energy use. These green features not only benefit the environment but also result in lower utility bills, making barndominiums a practical and eco-friendly housing choice. 

Note: “Consider installing rainwater collection systems to further enhance your home’s sustainability.”

Barndominiums Require Lower Maintenance

Steel exteriors require significantly less maintenance than traditional wood siding or shingles. This is particularly advantageous in Idaho, where weather conditions can cause conventional homes to wear and tear. Barndominiums are resistant to common issues like rot, termites, and mold, reducing the need for frequent repairs. The low maintenance requirements make barndominiums in Idaho a practical choice for busy residents.

Tip: “Inspect your barndominium annually to address minor issues before they escalate.”

The Cons of Building a Barndominium in Idaho

Financing for a Barndominium Can Be Difficult to Acquire

One of the biggest challenges with barndominiums is securing financing. Barndominium financing challenges arise because these homes are considered unconventional, making it difficult to qualify for traditional mortgages. Construction loans or personal loans are often required instead. This can add complexity to the home-buying process, but with careful planning, it’s a manageable hurdle.

Note: “Work with a lender experienced in barndominium financing to streamline the process.”

Purchasing a Barndominium Has Higher Upfront Costs

While barndominiums are cheaper in the long run, the upfront costs for materials and customization can be high. High-quality steel and unique design elements often increase initial expenses, which can be a barrier for some homeowners. By balancing upfront investments with future savings, homeowners can still achieve a cost-effective outcome.

Tip: “Consider breaking your project into phases to manage costs effectively.”

The Resale Market for Barndominiums Is Smaller

Barndominiums are a niche housing option, which can limit resale opportunities. The barndominium resale value may be affected by limited buyer interest, especially in Idaho’s less urbanized areas.

This makes it important to consider your long-term plans before building. Understanding the resale market is crucial for homeowners who may need to sell in the future.

Note: “Invest in features that appeal to a broad audience, such as energy efficiency and versatile layouts, to boost resale value.”

Barndominiums Are More Prone to Cracking or Shifting With Age

While durable, steel structures can develop issues like cracks or shifts over time, especially if the foundation isn’t properly installed. Idaho’s freeze-thaw cycles can exacerbate these problems, making preventative measures essential. Addressing these challenges during construction can prevent costly repairs later.

Tip: “Hire an experienced contractor to ensure a solid foundation and proper site preparation.”

The Metal of Your Barndominium Can Corrode Over Time

Idaho’s climate, particularly in humid or snowy areas, can lead to steel corrosion if not properly protected. Applying rust-resistant coatings and conducting regular inspections are key to maintaining the structure’s integrity. With proper maintenance, corrosion can be effectively managed, preserving the home’s longevity.

Note: “Invest in high-quality paints and coatings designed for Idaho’s weather conditions.”

Barndominiums Are Not Very Soundproof

Metal walls can amplify noise, making soundproofing a concern for barndominium owners. This is especially true in areas with high winds or busy households. Addressing acoustics during construction ensures a more peaceful living environment.

Tip: “Install insulation and acoustic panels to reduce noise levels and enhance comfort.”

Barndominiums Are Generally Only One-Story

Most barndominiums are single-story, which can be limiting for homeowners who prefer multi-level layouts. While adding a loft is possible, it requires careful planning to maintain structural integrity. Creative design solutions can help maximize the functionality of single-story homes.

Note: “Use high ceilings and open layouts to create the illusion of more vertical space.”

Some Cities Will Not Allow Barndominiums

Zoning restrictions and building codes can pose challenges for barndominium projects in Idaho. Researching local regulations and obtaining necessary permits is essential before starting construction. By ensuring compliance, homeowners can navigate these challenges successfully.

Tip: “Consult with local authorities early in the planning process to avoid delays or fines.”

Why Choose a Barndominium in Idaho?

Barndominiums in Idaho offer a unique combination of affordability, durability, and customization. Their spacious layouts and low maintenance needs align perfectly with the state’s rural lifestyle. Whether you’re a farmer, hobbyist, or growing family, a barndominium provides the flexibility and functionality you need.

How to Get Started on Your Barndominium Journey

Begin by partnering with experienced Idaho builders specializing in barndominiums. Planning your design, securing financing, and understanding local regulations are key steps in ensuring a successful project. With careful preparation, building a barndominium can be an exciting and rewarding experience.

Why Cascade Custom Construction is the Best Choice for Your Barndominium in Idaho

At Cascade Custom Construction, we pride ourselves on bringing your barndominium dreams to life. As Idaho’s trusted custom barndominium builder, we specialize in crafting homes that balance durability, cost-effectiveness, and personalized design. Whether you’re envisioning a rustic retreat or a modern masterpiece, we work closely with you to create a space that reflects your lifestyle and needs. From the first blueprint to the final touches, our streamlined process ensures your project stays on budget and on time.

What sets us apart? Our expertise in barndominium-specific construction. We understand Idaho’s unique climate challenges and build homes designed to withstand them while keeping you comfortable year-round. Plus, our commitment to eco-friendly practices means your barndominium will be as sustainable as it is stylish.

Conclusion

The pros and cons of barndominiums highlight their potential as affordable, eco-friendly, and durable housing options for Idaho residents. While challenges like financing and soundproofing exist, the benefits often outweigh the drawbacks. For those ready to embrace this unique housing trend, barndominiums in Idaho represent an exciting opportunity. Start your journey today and enjoy the rewards of building a home tailored to your lifestyle and values.

Let’s start building your dream barndominium! Reach out to Cascade Custom Construction at Contact Us to get started.